The Best EnergyStar Freezer For You To Own: A Buyers’ Comprehensive Guide

energy star freezer

An EnergyStar freezer can make your kitchen more energy efficient. But did you know it can also save you money?

It's true! In fact, replacing your old appliances with EnergyStar appliances can save you around 100 bucks every year per appliance in energy costs. On top of that, some appliances may even earn you a tax credit.

Which one should you buy? Lucky you, you're spoiled for choice. There are some excellent EnergyStar certified freezers on the market today. The following are some of our favorites.

Comparison Table

FAQs

What is the EnergyStar Program?

What is an EnergyStar Freezer?

What To Look For in a Freezer

Chest or upright?

How much freezer do you need?

How We Reviewed

  • First, we visited EnergyStar's residential freezer page, to see which models are covered under the program.
  • Then we consulted trusted review sites like Consumer Reports, to find the EnergyStar freezer models that they liked the best.
  • Finally, we took to the internet to see what actual purchasers thought of their new freezers.

As a result, we bring you an impartial, well-rounded list of what we believe to be the best EnergyStar freezers on the market today.

The Best EnergyStar Freezer To Own

Which freezer is ultimately the best? That's for you to decide. But to help you with your decision, here are our picks.

Large Freezers

Are you looking for somewhere to preserve the spoils of your latest hunting trip? Or perhaps your large household wants to have a large amount of food on hand in case of a family reunion? If this sounds like you, then a large freezer is what you need.

Kenmore Elite 27002 20.5 cu. ft. Upright Freezer in White, includes...
  • Item includes room of choice delivery, unboxing, item hook-up and free optional haul-away at checkout
  • Freeze Fresh Technology freezes food at -20 degrees to help lock in freshness and nutrients. Frost-free design means you...
  • Soft freeze zone is perfect for storing softer frozen goods like ice cream

Type of freezer:

Upright

Capacity (total volume):

20.5 cubic feet

Where to buy:

The Kenmore Elite 27002 is Consumer Report's top rated freezer model. They give it a rating of "excellent" for energy efficiency, temperature uniformity, temperature control, and ease of use. Consumer Search likewise considers this model good value for money.

Both reviewers and consumers found this model to be noisy. Also, Consumer Search was not impressed by the one-year warranty. Customer reviewers at Consumer Reports were less generous than Amazon reviewers, and rated this model 2.3 out of five, citing power failure performance and noise.


There seems to be a split, here, between consumer reviewers and professionals. Unfortunately, there weren't a lot of customer reviews. Consumer Reports tests thoroughly, though, so we'll put this one in the "needs more research" pile.

DMAFRIGFFFH21F6QW - Frigidaire 20.5 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer
  • 20.5 Cu. Ft. Capacity
  • Frost-Free Operation
  • Lock With Pop-Out Key

Type of freezer:

Upright

Capacity (total volume):

20.5 cubic feet

Where to buy:

Check Frigidaire's website to find a retailer near you

Consumer Reports rated this EnergyStar freezer very highly. In particular, they liked its energy efficiency and its performance on their lab tests. What's more, Consumer Search named it their Best Upright, calling it simple, reliable, and consistent.

Reviewers and consumers alike both found this freezer to be noisy. Critical consumer reviews also cited reliability as an issue.


After rigorous testing, The Wirecutter has declared this model to be the best of 2018. Consumers and reviewers both seemed to like this one, despite the noise. It also has a generous capacity. Reviewers consider this model to be very good value for money, as well.

GE FUF17DLRWW Upright Freezer
  • Interior LED lighting lets you see everything clearly so it's easier to find
  • Electronic external temperature control make adjusting the settings quick and simple
  • Lock and key deter thieves or unauthorized persons from accessing your frozen food

Type of freezer:

Upright

Capacity (total volume):

17.3 cubic feet

Consumer Reports rated this EnergyStar freezer highly for energy efficiency, temperature control, and stability. 

Consumers particularly liked the product quality and rated it good value for money.

There were a few consumer complaints about the door seal. In addition, several people found it noisy.


Consumers and reviewers seemed to be in sync on this one, also. And it looks like right now, you can get some very good deals on this particular EnergyStar freezer. If the price is right for you, then we think this is a good model.

GE FUF21SMRWW Upright Freezer
  • Interior LED lighting lets you see everything clearly so it's easier to find
  • Electronic external temperature control make adjusting the settings quick and simple
  • Lock and key deter thieves or unauthorized persons from accessing your frozen food

Type of freezer:

Upright

Capacity (total volume):

20 cubic feet

The Wirecutter considers this model to be the best overall freezer of 2018. In particular, they say it offers the storage space of a large freezer for the price of a smaller freezer. And that's important. Its features include a safety lock, adjustable legs, and adjustable shelves.

Numerous consumers reported breakdowns within a year of purchase.

As far as consumer reviews go, 1,563 of 2,137 people who bought this model from Home


Overall, consumers rated the unit highly for energy efficiency, quality, features, and value. Critical reviews focused on breakdowns.

GE FCM22DLWW Freezer
  • With a door that locks to help keep children out
  • Up-front temperature controls are easy to reach and operate
  • Lock with key allows you to protect your valuable food items from unintentional entry

Type of freezer:

Chest

Capacity (total volume):

21.7 cubic feet

Consumer Reports rated this model "excellent" or "very good" in all categories. Purchaser reviews were few and far between. Those who left reviews, however, praised its power outage performance and general quality.

We were unable to find a significant number of either consumer or professional reviews of this model.


However, we included it on our list, because both Consumer Reports, which tests products thoroughly and verified purchasers at several outlets rated this EnergyStar freezer very highly. We are optimistic but will be keeping our eyes open for long-term reports.

Compact Freezers

Does your household need a bit of extra freezer space, but not enough to justify buying a large, standalone unit? Consider a compact. There are quite a few good ones out there. Here are a few.

GE FCM11PHWW Chest Freezer
  • With a door that locks to help keep children out
  • Up-front temperature controls are easy to reach and operate
  • Lock with key allows you to protect your valuable food items from unintentional entry

Type of freezer:

Chest

Capacity (total volume):

10.6 cubic feet

Consumer Reports loved this model and rated it "excellent" in most categories. It did get dinged, though, on "ease of use." Verified purchasers are overwhelmingly enthusiastic.

Consumer criticisms seemed to focus on issues with the compressor and temperature control. A number of customers were also displeased that the unit doesn't come with a back cover where the power cord is located.

They especially liked that it was good value for the money. The Wirecutter considers this one of the best chest freezers out there, regarding price, specs, efficiency, and footprint.


On top of that, right now, it looks like you can get some excellent deals on it. We give this model our enthusiastic thumbs up.

Type of freezer:

Compact Upright

Capacity (total volume):

15.7 cubic feet

This chest has a small footprint, but a very decent capacity. Additionally, reviewers and purchasers alike all considered this unit to be very good for its price.


Despite what reviewers considered to be a comprehensive warranty, there were numerous consumer complaints about dealing with Maytag service.

1,037 out of 1,455 people who purchased this model from Home Depot. Consumers liked the unit's quality, value, features, and energy efficiency equally well.


Complaints seemed to center around difficulty obtaining needed repairs from Maytag, even under a warranty that reviewers praised.

Danby DUFM085A2WDD1 Upright Freezer, 8.5 Cubic Feet, White
  • 8.5 cu.ft. interior capacity
  • Loading Capacity : 8.5 cubic feet (or) equivalent to a maximum of 241 Liters
  • 3 quick freeze shelves

Type of freezer:

Compact Upright

Capacity (total volume):

3.2 to 8.5

Where to buy:

The Spruce liked this unit's energy efficiency measures, including extra insulation. They also liked the fact that it uses an environmentally friendly refrigerant called R600a. Also, they loved the adjustable temperature controls.

Consumer Reports praises the energy efficiency of this EnergyStar freezer, although it does take points off for ease of use. Sixty-five percent of more than 400 Amazon purchasers.


They were impressed by the unit's quality, as well as its storage capacity. If you're looking for a compact, this might be one to keep your eye on.

Our Verdict

If you're looking for a large-capacity freezer, then it's pretty hard to go wrong with the GE FUF17DLRWW. Why? Well, both consumers and reviewers seemed to like it a lot. In addition, the problems that consumers reported seemed minor by comparison.

Finally, it looks like if this is the machine for you, you can get a great deal on it right now.

As far as compacts go, we're with the GE FCM11PHWW -- again, because of the enthusiastic reviews from both customers and professionals.

So, which EnergyStar freezer is for you? And have we missed out on any great models? Let us know in the comments!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here